Profitability, Policy, and the Road Ahead
If Part 1 traced the dramatic growth and fragility of Indian aviation, Part 2 examines why profitability remains elusive, the structural and regulatory bottlenecks that reinforce fragility, and what can realistically be done to secure the sector’s future.
Despite soaring passenger numbers, airlines struggle to convert traffic into profits. Fuel is the largest single cost: ATF taxes in India are among the world’s highest, sometimes exceeding 30–35% of ticket revenue. Airport charges further inflate costs. Indian passengers are extremely price-sensitive, and fare caps under schemes like UDAN often render routes financially unsustainable. Ancillary revenues—cargo, business-class premiums, lounges—remain limited compared to global peers. As a result, passenger growth alone does not ensure financial stability.
Historical patterns confirm this paradox. Legacy carriers like Jet Airways and Go First collapsed; SpiceJet has oscillated between losses and recovery for years. IndiGo remains profitable, but its dominance leaves the sector structurally fragile. Minimal redundancy means that if the largest carrier falters, the system experiences cascading failures, as the December crisis demonstrated.
Regulatory complexity compounds these challenges. Rules like the “5/20” requirement and Route Dispersal Guidelines, combined with micromanagement by regulators, create uncertainty. Even fare adjustments are fraught: airlines face scrutiny for raising prices, while fuel taxes and airport fees can spike without warning. The result is a market that is deregulated in theory but tightly constrained in practice.
Short-term challenges for new entrants, recently licensed by the government, are formidable. Airlines require years to reach operational maturity: aircraft procurement, crew training, route allocation, and airport slots all demand careful planning and substantial capital. Without predictable taxation and regulatory clarity, new carriers risk joining the growing list of airline failures before achieving scale.
Infrastructure constraints remain significant. Dozens of underutilized airports highlight the disconnect between infrastructure expansion and operational sustainability. Without financially viable airlines, even newly built airports cannot stimulate local economies. Alternative transport modes—railways and roads—cannot absorb sudden aviation disruptions, further emphasizing the importance of resilient air services.
Addressing these challenges requires both short-term and medium-term strategies. In the near term, rationalizing ATF taxes and airport fees would reduce immediate cost pressures. Streamlining regulations—simplifying route dispersal obligations, clarifying fare policies, and reducing unpredictable interventions—would enhance operational confidence. Support for new entrants, such as targeted capital or temporary incentives, could help them survive initial years while building operational scale.
Medium-term reforms must focus on resilience and competition. Encouraging multiple carriers on the same routes, fostering financially sustainable low-cost carriers, and enabling market-based pricing are critical. Policy must recognize that aviation is strategic infrastructure: stable airlines enhance connectivity, commerce, and national growth. Lessons from Singapore or Dubai show that treating aviation as a national instrument—rather than merely a revenue source—yields long-term benefits.
The prognosis is cautiously optimistic. India’s domestic air travel will likely continue its upward trajectory, driven by rising incomes, urbanization, and consumer aspiration. Yet without structural reforms, policy clarity, and financial prudence, crises like the IndiGo meltdown may recur. New entrants will face the same pressures as their predecessors unless the economics of Indian aviation are corrected.
Ultimately, India’s aviation sector is at a crossroads. Its infrastructure is impressive, its market large, and its consumer base aspirational. But growth alone is insufficient; stability, competition, and financial viability are essential. Until this balance is struck, India will continue producing passengers in record numbers—and, tragically, state funerals for airlines struggling to survive in skies engineered for fragility.
scribo ad LX 